Cawley received 202 votes with Reed netting 204.
Place 4 was a contested race between incumbent Peggy Sonnenberg and Stan Peavy. Peavy won the race with 135 votes to Sonnenberg's 106.
Newcastle City Council election winners are Jerry Stewart, 49 votes; Kris Brice, 33, votes; and Melba Quaid, 32 votes.
Results for others in the election were Dewayne Belcer, 16 votes; Jo Cox, 29 votes; Robert Maddox, 23 votes; and Pam Myers, 22 votes.